The plan by the Kaduna State Governor, Nasir El-Rufai and other North-West governors to hire foreign mercenaries to help fight the insurgency in the region has been described as unconstitutional.
Following the Monday night attack, where terrorists bombed a Kaduna-bound train with nearly 400 passengers and rail workers onboard, El-Rufai said he and his colleagues in the North-West would not mind hiring foreign mercenaries if the Federal Government failed to secure the country.
He spoke on Friday to State House correspondents after he visited the President, Maj. Gen. Muhammadu Buhari (retd.), at the Presidential Villa.
According to him, Monday night’s attack on the Abuja-Kaduna train, which left eight passengers dead, 21 still uncounted for and several others injured, could have been avoided if the Federal Government had heeded his earlier warnings.
Speaking in Hausa after the meeting, El-Rufai said, “Why is it that up till now, the security has not gone to kill them? Where are our soldiers? Why have they not done it? That is why I have come to see Mr President.
“And also I have said that if these actions are not taken, it becomes a must for us as governors to take measures to protect our citizens, even if it means we will import mercenaries from outside the country to do it. If our soldiers fail, I swear to God, we will do that. This issue has reached an alarming state.”
However, some Senior Advocates of Nigeria had warned against such a move describing it as unconstitutional.
A human rights lawyer and senior advocate, Mr Femi Falana, said Buhari remained the commander-in-chief and that only he could approve the deployment of mercenaries.
Falana, in a message he sent to Sunday PUNCH, argued that any move by El-Rufai or any of the governors to hire foreign mercenaries would be unconstitutional
He said, “By virtue of Section 130 of the constitution, the President is the Commander-in-Chief of the Armed Forces. Governors are not competent to hire mercenaries to secure any part of Nigeria. Frankly speaking, Nigerian soldiers are ready to wage counter-insurgency operations but they are ill-equipped and ill-motivated.”
Falana said Nigeria had one of the best military capabilities in the world but alleged that resources meant for them were being stolen by a few unpatriotic officers and members of the ruling class.
He added, “The constitution provides for the creation of the Nigeria Police Council made of the President as the Chair, the Inspector-General of Police, Chair of the Police Service Commission and the 36 state governors.
“Apart from physical security, the federating units are not addressing the crisis of social insecurity. 90 million citizens have been forced into the cocoon of poverty. About 15 million out of school children are roaming the streets, ready to be recruited by criminal gangs. These are the challenges of insecurity to be addressed. This is not a job for mercenaries.”
Another senior advocate, Mr Ahmed Raji, faulted El-Rufai’s threat. According to Raji, hiring external hands to fight terrorists was not just unconstitutional, but would dampen the image of the Nigerian military in the global space.
He warned El-Rufai to tread with caution as this might open doors to bigger problems and “signal the end of a united Nigeria.”
Raji added, “I don’t think states can bring in mercenaries. I can see the frustration of the affected states but allowing states to bring in mercenaries may open doors to bigger problems that may signal the end of a united Nigeria. Any state can then contrive a crisis and bring in mercenaries to different parts of Nigeria which may compromise our security system and unity.
“The Federal Government has a duty to maintain internal security and where necessary it should involve external aid including mercenaries. It should only be a last resort because inviting mercenaries does not reflect well on the image of our security officials and their morale. I tend to see the alert by the Kaduna Governor as an empathic wake-up call to the Federal Government. The governor knows better.”
Also reacting, Chief Mike Ozekhome (SAN), said hiring mercenaries was like stirring the hornet’s nest.
He warned El-Rufai and the other governors to rescind their plans as they had no powers to do so.
“No state government under our constitutional democracy and legal regime can unilaterally act to invite mercenaries to Nigeria. It is ‘ultra vires’ their powers. Their only resort is a collaborative rapprochement with the Federal government. However, they can tackle their state security matters within the permissible limits of our constitutional organogram.
“The engagement of external mercenaries is akin to the deployment of the military to repel and contain external aggression. It has to do with the command and operational use of the Armed Forces of Nigeria, whether in peace times, war, or under a state of emergency. All of these are solely and wholly vested in the President, with some moderate effect by the National Assembly according to Sections 217, 218, 219 and 305 of the 1999 Constitution.”
Human rights lawyer, Mr Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa (SAN), also faulted the plan to hire foreign mercenaries, adding that governors had no such constitutional powers.
Adegboruwa called for restructuring so that states could play a pivotal role in security issues in the country. He stressed that Governor El-Rufai was “shedding crocodile tears” since his party gave false impressions that they would restructure the country.
He also criticised the governor for lambasting the Goodluck Jonathan government when the administration proposed employing mercenaries to tackle the menace. He urged Governor El-Rufai to revisit and help implement the resolutions of the Committee on Restructuring led by him.
“Under our law, no governor has statutory powers to dabble into powers concerning security. Members of the armed forces of the Federal Republic of Nigeria have exclusive power to defend the national integrity of Nigeria and also to wage war against insurrection, so there is no provision in our laws to bring in mercenaries,” the senior advocate added.
Also speaking with Sunday PUNCH, Mr Yusuf Ali (SAN) said that irrespective of the situation on the ground, the North-West governors must act according to the law of the land.
He said, “Governors don’t have the primary authority to control nor set up private armed forces. Hire mercenaries to work with whom? When the country hires one, they work with their Armed Forces. You have to go by the rule of law, no matter the state of insecurity otherwise it would lead to a state of anarchy.”
IED kills three soldiers as NAF bombs terrorists
An improvised explosive device planted by terrorists has killed at least three soldiers along Kaduna-Abuja.
This is as the airstrikes by the Nigerian Air Force killed 50 terrorists in Zamfara and 33 in Kaduna states, according to sources.
According to sources, the troops’ vehicle on Saturday hit the device on their way to an operation in the area.
Theatre Commander of Operation Hadin Kai in Maiduguri, Borno, Major General Chris Musa, had said terrorists had carried out no fewer than 81 attacks using IEDs between January and March 2022.
With this attack, the terrorists had used IEDs on the military 82 times this year, he said.
The source said, “The troops were heading for an operation along the Kaduna-Abuja road when they stepped on an IED planted by the terrorists. Three died on the spot while others were injured. This happened on Saturday morning.”
Efforts to get the reaction of the Director, Defence Media Operations, Major General Benard Onyeuko, were not successful as he didn’t answer calls to his lines and failed to respond to a text message.
Meanwhile, there were simultaneous airstrikes from the Nigerian Air Force fighter jets in Sangeko Forest in Zamfara, New Kusawa in Kaduna and Tumbuns in Borno State,
A military source said, “Overnight Intelligence, Surveillance and Reconnaissance was first conducted between March 30 and 31, 2022, at Kusasu.”
The ISR, however, revealed that four troops on motorcycles who departed the location to a slightly bushy area southwards of Kusasu counted about 33 terrorists’ bodies, while others dispersed in various directions.’’
The NAF Spokesperson, Air Commodore Edward Gabkwet, confirmed the air operations.