A fresh leadership crisis has engulfed the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) following a split judgment by the Supreme Court of Nigeria nullifying a key party convention.
In a 3–2 decision delivered by a five-member panel led by Justice Mohammed Garba, the apex court upheld earlier rulings of the lower courts which invalidated the convention held in Ibadan.
The majority judgment, supported by Justices Chioma Nwosu-Iheme and Stephen Adah, held that the appellants acted in disobedience to a valid subsisting judgment of the Federal High Court.
The court ruled that being in contempt, the appellants could not be granted relief, leading to the dismissal of the appeal.
However, the minority judgment delivered by Justices Haruna Tsammani and Abubakar Umar disagreed, arguing that the matter bordered on the internal affairs of the PDP and was therefore non-justiciable.
They maintained that the case did not involve any action of a federal government agency and should not have been entertained by the courts.
The dissenting justices also faulted the majority for raising issues suo motu without giving parties the opportunity to respond, describing the approach as inconsistent with established judicial principles.
The ruling also affirmed the suspension of some party figures, including Ajibade (SAN) and Anyanwu, further deepening uncertainty within the opposition party.
Reacting to the judgment, spokesperson for a faction identified as the “Uncompromised PDP,” Comrade Ini Ememobong, warned that the decision leaves the party without a clearly defined leadership structure.
He expressed optimism that existing organs of the party would take urgent steps to stabilise the situation, but cautioned that the development poses a significant threat not only to the PDP but also to Nigeria’s multi-party democracy if not carefully managed.