Mr. Taiwo Oyedele, Chairman of the Presidential Tax Reform Committee, has raised concerns over the potential economic impact if state governments are permitted to independently collect Value-Added Tax (VAT). According to Oyedele, such a shift could spell significant trouble for businesses and overall economic health.
Oyedele recalled a similar scenario in the 1980s when sub-national governments attempted to generate revenue through sales tax but faced challenges in raising significant funds. Drawing a parallel, he emphasized that VAT—a key revenue source today—was not originally included in Nigeria’s 1979 Constitution because it didn’t exist at the time. However, by the 1999 Constitution, VAT had been implemented for about five years, yet was omitted from the new constitution. “This absence has led lawyers to argue that VAT falls under the residual list, granting states the authority to collect it,” Oyedele explained.
Rivers and Lagos States, citing this constitutional gap, have pursued legal victories allowing them to collect VAT at the state level.
However, Oyedele warns that a Supreme Court judgment in favor of state-controlled VAT could introduce chaos, resulting in reduced revenue collection, business setbacks, and economic decline.
“The new reform aims to provide equitable treatment and correct misconceptions that state-controlled VAT will yield substantial revenue,” he said. He also pointed out that a significant portion of VAT is generated from imports and international services, revenue currently pooled and shared among states rather than attributed to specific ones.
Under the existing VAT sharing formula, 50% is distributed equally among states, 30% based on population, and 20% on derivation.
Oyedele proposed a revised formula favoring derivation with 60%, while population and equality each account for 20%, aiming to balance equity with local revenue generation.