Home News SIGNED BUT NOT ENFORCED: THE CONSEQUENCES OF NIGERIA’S FAILURE TO DOMESTICATE GENDER JUSTICE TREATIES

SIGNED BUT NOT ENFORCED: THE CONSEQUENCES OF NIGERIA’S FAILURE TO DOMESTICATE GENDER JUSTICE TREATIES

0
SIGNED BUT NOT ENFORCED: THE CONSEQUENCES OF NIGERIA’S FAILURE TO DOMESTICATE GENDER JUSTICE TREATIES

 

By Oluwatoyin Omotayo Esq

Nigeria has repeatedly affirmed its commitment to protecting women and girls from domestic and gender-based violence (DGBV) by ratifying key international and regional human rights instruments. Yet, for millions of survivors across the country, these commitments remain largely symbolic. The failure of the Nigerian government to domesticate critical international laws has created a dangerous legal lacuna, one that continues to undermine survivor protection, weaken accountability, and perpetuate impunity.
Under Nigerian constitutional law, international treaties do not automatically become enforceable domestically. Section 12 of the 1999 Constitution explicitly requires domestication by the National Assembly before treaty provisions can have the force of law. It is within this legal gap that survivors of domestic and gender-based violence are left exposed.
International Commitments Without Domestic Force
Nigeria is a signatory to the Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) and has also ratified the Maputo Protocol on the Rights of Women in Africa. Both instruments impose clear obligations on states to prevent violence, protect survivors, prosecute perpetrators, and address the structural inequalities that enable abuse.
CEDAW, particularly through General Recommendation No. 35, defines gender-based violence as a form of discrimination and introduces the principle of state due diligence. The Maputo Protocol goes further by explicitly requiring states to criminalise violence against women and provide effective remedies and support services.
Despite ratification, neither CEDAW nor the Maputo Protocol has been domesticated in Nigeria. As a result, their provisions are not directly enforceable in Nigerian courts. Survivors cannot rely on them to compel government action, and judges are not legally bound to apply their standards.
The Legal Lacuna and Its Human Cost
The consequences of this non-domestication are not abstract; they are lived realities for survivors.
First, access to justice becomes geographically unequal. While the Violence Against Persons (Prohibition) Act (VAPP Act) provides a progressive framework, it applies only in the Federal Capital Territory and in states that have domesticated it. Survivors in states without equivalent legislation are often left to rely on outdated criminal and penal codes that fail to recognise psychological, economic, or coercive abuse.
Second, state accountability is significantly weakened. International law requires governments to act with due diligence in preventing and responding to violence, including failures by police, prosecutors, or social services. In Nigeria, survivors rarely succeed in holding the state accountable for institutional failures because the legal basis for such claims, that is the international treaties, has not been domesticated.
Third, survivor remedies are limited and inconsistent. International instruments emphasise holistic redress, including compensation, rehabilitation, and guarantees of non-repetition. Nigerian law, by contrast, remains largely punitive rather than restorative, offering little in the way of state-funded survivor support.
Cultural Defences and Legal Silence
The absence of domesticated international standards also allows harmful cultural and social norms to continue shaping legal outcomes. Without binding treaty obligations, domestic violence is too often trivialised as a “family matter,” mediation is prioritised over justice, and survivors are pressured to reconcile with abusers.
Domestication would strengthen judicial interpretation, empowering courts to reject victim-blaming narratives and recognise domestic and gender-based violence as a violation of fundamental human rights.
Policy Promises Without Legal Backing
Nigeria has developed policies, action plans, and institutional frameworks addressing gender-based violence. However, without domesticated international obligations, these initiatives remain vulnerable to political changes, inconsistent funding, and weak enforcement.
Domesticated treaties would elevate these commitments from policy aspirations to legal mandates, compelling sustained government action and resource allocation.
Why Domestication Matters
Domestication is not about importing foreign values; it is about translating Nigeria’s own commitments into enforceable law. It would harmonise protections across states, strengthen survivor-centred justice, and align Nigeria’s domestic laws with international best practices.
Most importantly, domestication would shift the narrative from government goodwill to government obligation.
Conclusion
Nigeria’s failure to domesticate critical international instruments on domestic and gender-based violence represents more than a legislative oversight, it is a systemic failure that leaves survivors inadequately protected. Ratification without domestication creates the illusion of commitment while denying survivors meaningful access to justice.
Until Nigeria closes this legal gap, domestic and gender-based violence will continue to thrive in the shadows of unenforced promises. True protection begins not with signatures on international documents, but with the courage to transform those commitments into binding, enforceable law that places survivor dignity, safety, and justice at the centre of governance.

Oluwatoyin Omotayo Esq is the
Founder TOOF