Former Vice President and presidential aspirant, Alhaji Atiku Abubakar, has unveiled his economic position ahead of the 2027 general election, proposing the restoration of petrol subsidy if elected President.
The proposal represents a major departure from Atiku’s earlier position that the petrol subsidy regime should be removed. During the build-up to the 2023 presidential election, he had advocated the elimination of the subsidy as part of his economic agenda.
His latest position has therefore raised questions about the economic rationale and feasibility of returning to a policy that has been widely criticised for imposing a heavy burden on public finances.
Atiku is constitutionally entitled to propose alternative policies and seek the support of Nigerians. However, any proposal to restore petrol subsidy should be subjected to careful scrutiny, particularly in view of the legal, fiscal and structural changes that have taken place in Nigeria’s petroleum sector since 2023.
The subsidy regime that Nigerians operated under before May 2023 was dismantled as part of broader petroleum-sector reforms. The Petroleum Industry Act (PIA) provided a new framework for the downstream petroleum market and scheduled the end of the subsidy regime by June 2023. President Bola Tinubu subsequently accelerated its removal.
Restoring the old arrangement would therefore require more than a presidential announcement.
It would require a clear legal, fiscal and administrative framework, including identifying the source of funding and determining how subsidy payments would be implemented under the current petroleum-market structure.
There is also a need to clarify what is meant by petrol subsidy. It is not simply money sitting in government coffers waiting to be distributed to consumers. Under the previous arrangement, government effectively absorbed the difference between the cost of supplying petrol and the regulated pump price, creating substantial financial obligations and under-recovery costs.
Claims about trillions of naira allegedly saved through subsidy removal must also be subjected to proper fiscal analysis. Nigerians deserve clear figures showing the actual cost of subsidy, the outstanding obligations and the savings accruing to the government since its removal.
More importantly, Nigeria’s petroleum industry has changed significantly since 2023. The country has moved from a heavy dependence on imported petrol towards increased domestic refining, with the Dangote Refinery becoming a major source of locally refined petroleum products.
This emerging refining capacity has the potential to strengthen energy security, conserve foreign exchange, create jobs and develop Nigeria’s industrial base.
The current market-driven environment has also created opportunities for Nigeria to participate more actively in the export of refined petroleum products, rather than relying predominantly on imported refined products.
Returning to the old subsidy regime could therefore introduce distortions into a sector that is gradually adjusting to domestic refining and market-based pricing. It could also create uncertainty for emerging local refineries and discourage further private investment in refining capacity.
For many years, Nigeria spent billions of dollars importing refined petroleum products despite being a major crude oil producer. The country’s petroleum economy was characterised by a dependence on imported petrol and a subsidy system that placed substantial pressure on government finances.
At various times, the subsidy burden was financed through borrowing and other public-sector arrangements. The result was an accumulation of obligations that placed additional pressure on the Nigerian National Petroleum Company Limited and the wider public finances.
The central question for any proposal to restore subsidy is therefore straightforward: Who will pay for it?
If petrol is sold below its economic cost, government must absorb the difference. That would ultimately affect public finances through reduced resources for infrastructure and social services, lower allocations to states and local governments, increased borrowing, higher public debt or a combination of these consequences.
There is no doubt that the removal of subsidy has increased the cost of living and placed significant pressure on households and businesses. Higher petrol prices have contributed to increased transportation and production costs.
However, sustainable relief for Nigerians should not necessarily mean recreating a fiscal arrangement that previously placed enormous pressure on government finances.
The Federal Government has instead promoted alternative energy sources, including Compressed Natural Gas (CNG), as a cheaper option for motorists and commercial transport operators. CNG, which is significantly cheaper than petrol in many applications, has increasingly been adopted by businesses and transport operators.
The challenge now is to ensure that the savings from cheaper energy sources translate into lower transportation and distribution costs for ordinary Nigerians.
The subsidy debate must therefore be based on the realities of Nigeria’s current petroleum market rather than the conditions that existed several years ago.
Political promises must also be backed by clear fiscal arithmetic.
If Atiku Abubakar proposes to restore petrol subsidy, Nigerians deserve answers to critical questions: How much will the programme cost annually? What revenue source will finance it? Will the government borrow to fund it? Will existing petroleum-sector legislation have to be amended? How will subsidy payments be monitored and protected from fraud and abuse?
And with Nigeria’s domestic refining capacity expanding, what exactly would the proposed subsidy finance—the cost of local production, transportation, distribution or another component of the petroleum value chain?
Nigeria cannot afford to return to policies whose costs are hidden from citizens only to reappear later as debt, reduced public spending and pressure on the national currency.
The country should welcome robust debate on the cost of living and alternative economic policies. However, such debate must be anchored in Nigeria’s present economic and petroleum realities.
Political actors, including Atiku Abubakar, should therefore provide Nigerians with the full fiscal, legal and economic implications of any proposal to restore petrol subsidy before asking citizens to support it.
Bayo Onanuga
Special Adviser to the President
(Information and Strategy)