Home Analysis Presidency Questions Frequent Electoral Law Amendments, Downplays Real-Time Result

Presidency Questions Frequent Electoral Law Amendments, Downplays Real-Time Result

0

Transmission Debate
The Presidency has cautioned against Nigeria’s frequent amendments to electoral laws, arguing that constant legal tinkering before every election cycle does not necessarily translate into more credible polls.

In a statement titled “Beyond the Compulsory Real-Time Electronic Transmission of Results,” the Presidency said the common justification of “continuous improvement” for repeated amendments fails under closer scrutiny, noting that stable democracies do not rewrite their electoral laws every four years.

According to the statement, countries such as the United States, the United Kingdom, Germany, France, South Africa, Ghana and Benin Republic conduct regular elections without routinely amending their electoral frameworks.

Their progress, it argued, comes from institutional maturity, stronger enforcement mechanisms and the internalisation of democratic norms by political actors, rather than constant changes to the law.

The Presidency maintained that while it supports compulsory electronic transmission of election results, it would be overly optimistic to assume that inserting such a provision into law would automatically improve electoral outcomes.

“Laws do not conduct elections. People do,” the statement said, stressing that Nigeria’s electoral challenges are more rooted in conduct and institutional discipline than in legal provisions.
It also criticised what it described as an overreliance on “buzzwords” by political actors and sections of civil society, noting that each election cycle tends to generate new reform slogans that create the appearance of progress without addressing core behavioural issues.

Referencing the controversy surrounding the 2023 presidential election, the Presidency pointed out that the candidate who finished third has continued to claim victory years after the poll, attributing his loss to alleged rigging and the failure to transmit results in real time to the IReV portal.

The statement noted that nearly three years after the election that produced President Bola Tinubu, results from over 170,000 polling units have long been uploaded to the portal. It added that if discrepancies truly existed between polling unit results and those published online, political parties, civil society groups and election observers would have had ample time to present credible counter-results.
“None has done so, and this silence is telling,” the Presidency said.
Emphasising that voting, counting and result documentation at polling units are still conducted manually, the statement argued that whether results are transmitted instantly or later does not change what was recorded and signed by party agents at the polling units.
While acknowledging that technology can enhance transparency, the Presidency stressed that it cannot “manufacture outcomes.” It identified the introduction of the Permanent Voter’s Card and electronic accreditation through the BVAS as Nigeria’s most significant electoral reforms since 1958, noting that these measures have drastically reduced ballot stuffing and election-day malpractice.
The Presidency concluded that although the National Assembly may include compulsory real-time transmission of results to provide reassurance to aggrieved parties, it should do so without unrealistic expectations.
“Nigeria does not suffer from a shortage of electoral laws,” the statement said. “It suffers from a shortage of democratic restraint, institutional discipline and political maturity.”