BY TAIWO OGUNMOLA-OMILANI
The Nigeria Employers’ Consultative Association (NECA) has said 60 years after independence, the industrial relations system is still characterised with visible decay.
The NECA Director-General, Mr. Olawale Timothy disclosed this in a statement made available to Upshot on the independence celebration of Nigeria at 60.
According to NECA, the colonialists established an industrial relations system characterised with a structure of an admixture of the Anglo-Saxon model of tripartism – a system of industrial relations which involved interaction among the key actors: employers, employees and government) and interventionism, which rely on the use of force to enforce compliance and prevention of industrial action.
Olawale stressed that with the exit of the colonial masters, efforts to build strong structures to facilitate rapid industrial relations growth have not yielded significant success.
“While some progress has been made in developing industrial relations legal framework, sixty years after independence, the industrial relations system is still characterised with visible decay.
“Against the expectations of critical stakeholders, there is still little or no collective bargaining going on, particularly in the Public Sector. Negotiations now operate mostly in crisis mode. Memorandums of Understandings, which are a strange terminology in Collective Bargaining, have replaced collective agreement”, Olawale added.
NECA DG posited that the development of Industrial Relations in Nigeria is one that cannot be divorced from colonial history, saying the system was foisted bequeathed to the post-colonial independent Nigerian government led by the Sir Abubakar Tafawa Balewa.
His words: “The lines of rights of Trade Unions on negotiable matters and information issues have long disappeared. Rather than being the last resort for dispute resolution, strikes have become the first resort and even at that, lines of authority and the provision in the union’s constitution for the convening of strikes are hardly respected.
“Both the grievance settlement and the dispute settlement machineries only exist on paper as it is viewed and treated with contempt and ignominy. Contrary to the spirit and letter of dispute settlement, the Minister of Labour and Employment has assumed the role of the chief conciliator in major disputes. Intra-union disputes and the flagrant disregard for judicial interpretation and intervention in labour disputes have perpetually created a siege situation in labour adjudication. These, amongst many others have contributed to the decadent state of our industrial relations system.
“While the various decrees and enactments under the Military regimes at different times provided the legal frameworks for industrial relations practice and collective bargaining amongst others, social partners (Government, Employers and labour) have legalistic reference points or bases to indulge in negotiations. Notwithstanding the provisions of the Trade Dispute Act of 1976, dispute resolutions remain fractured with consequential effects on productivity, enterprise competitiveness and national development”.
In proffering solutions, Olawale said “As a first step in rectifying the anomaly, it is imperative for Government to give life to the National Labour Advisory Council (NLAC). A body that ought to be saddled with the responsibility of coordinating the institutional relationship between Social Partners. While the NLAC will not on its own solve all issues, it will serve as a veritable platform on which our Industrial Relations system can be built on the short and long run”.
NECA in summarising the industrial relations system in Nigeria since independence said, “it can be averred that it has been faced and continue to be faced with the following challenges:
•The continuous demand for the implementation of the National Minimum Wage and better wage conditions.
•The quest for better working conditions, poor consultation and involvement of labour unions on labour related issues by government.
•Poor enforcement of the labour laws and lack of political will to sufficiently review the obsolete labour laws.
•Disregard for negotiated agreements by Government.•Disregard for judicial pronouncements and verdicts of the relevant courts.
•The non-functional state of the National Labour Advisory Council which is the structured avenue to nip any industrial crisis in the bud.•Ineffective Labour inspection and administration.
•High number of Industrial disputes, especially in the public sector which has negatively impacted the mechanisms or procedures for dispute settlement. •Intra-Union disputes. The split and the eventual unification of the Labour Unions (NLC and ULC).
•The moribund state of Employers’ Associations in some sectors such as the Financial Sector, which prevents Employers and Employees from engaging in collecting bargaining.
•Labour’s disregard for due process before embarking on strike actions.
•Disdain and impunity for the rule of law and absence of Procedural Agreement, especially in the public sector.
•Lack of expertise and capacity to manage labour relations. Outside the Ministry of Labour, there appears to be an absence of expertise at the MDAs and the States to provide labour relations’ guidance and management support.