The Lagos State University Teaching Hospital (LASUTH) has told a coroner’s court investigating the death of journalist Pelumi Onifade that it was unable to identify a body believed to be his because all DNA samples held at the Lagos State DNA and Forensic Centre were destroyed when the facility was burnt during the #EndSARS protests in October 2020.
However, Media Rights Agenda (MRA), which initiated the coroner’s inquest, has challenged the explanation, describing it as inconsistent with the known timeline of events surrounding the death of the late journalist.
At the resumed hearing on Tuesday, April 7, 2026, the District Coroner, Mrs. Temitope Oladele, noted that LASUTH had finally submitted a report in compliance with an earlier court order directing it to provide a “comprehensive and specific report” on an unidentified body tagged 1385, believed to be that of Onifade.
According to LASUTH’s report, all DNA samples in the custody of the Lagos State DNA and Forensic Centre, located within its premises, were destroyed when the centre was set ablaze during the #EndSARS unrest.
But lead counsel to MRA, Mr. Alimi Adamu, disputed the hospital’s position, arguing that the explanation could not stand in light of official records showing that the DNA Centre was burnt on October 23, 2020 — a day before Onifade was reportedly shot by police on October 24, 2020 while covering the protests.
Adamu pointed out that DNA samples from members of Onifade’s family were collected several days after his death, making it impossible for those samples to have been among materials destroyed in the fire.
He told the court that the chronology of events made LASUTH’s explanation “manifestly inconsistent” and incapable of being reconciled with the established facts.
According to him, although he was not alleging bad faith on the part of any institution, the contradiction in the report raised serious concerns that required clarification in order to preserve the integrity of the inquest.
Adamu further informed the court that Pelumi’s parents, who were present during the proceedings, had subsequent interactions with LASUTH officials, including the Chief Pathologist, Professor John Obafunwa, after the DNA samples were taken.
He said at no point were they informed that the samples had been compromised, destroyed, or that fresh samples would be required.
The lawyer added that the deceased’s parents were willing to testify on oath if the court deemed it necessary.
The inquest has suffered repeated delays due to LASUTH’s failure to comply with the coroner’s order first issued on November 18, 2025, directing the hospital to produce a report on the body tagged 1385, on which a post-mortem examination was reportedly conducted in November 2020.
The delay had stalled progress in the inquiry for nearly five months.
At the previous sitting on March 24, 2026, the coroner declined an application by Adamu seeking committal proceedings against LASUTH’s Chief Medical Director for alleged disobedience of the court’s order, opting instead to give the hospital a final opportunity to comply.
The coroner’s inquest into Onifade’s death was instituted following an order of the Federal High Court in Lagos in a suit filed by MRA against the Nigeria Police Force and the Lagos State Government.
In a judgment delivered on July 19, 2024, Justice Ayokunle Olayinka Faji directed the Lagos State Attorney-General to ensure a proper investigation into the circumstances surrounding Onifade’s death, including the conduct of a coroner’s inquest to establish the cause of death and identify those responsible.
During Tuesday’s proceedings, the coroner observed that while the issue of the DNA samples was significant, the immediate priority of the court was to determine the identification, location and production of the body, which she described as the central subject of the inquest.
She noted that information before the court suggested that the body had been transferred from LASUTH to another facility in the Yaba area of Lagos.
According to her, resolving the question of the body’s whereabouts was fundamental to the progress of the inquiry, while issues relating to DNA analysis could be revisited once clarity had been established on the custody and status of the remains.
Adamu, however, urged the court to allow efforts to locate and produce the body to proceed simultaneously with steps relating to DNA analysis or re-sampling in the interest of expeditious justice.
The coroner agreed with the proposal and stressed the need for direct clarification from all relevant institutions, especially in view of the apparent inconsistencies in LASUTH’s account.
She also said the court was prepared to grant relatively short adjournments in order to ensure prompt compliance with its directives and avoid unnecessary delays.
Following an application by Adamu, the coroner ordered the Chief Medical Director of the Yaba facility to which the body was reportedly transferred to produce a detailed report on the whereabouts and status of the body bearing Tag No. 1385 within 14 days of being served with the order.
The matter was subsequently adjourned to April 28, 2026.