Home News Firm Alleges Bias, Fraud in CBN’s Handling of Excess Bank Charges Refund by First Bank

Firm Alleges Bias, Fraud in CBN’s Handling of Excess Bank Charges Refund by First Bank

0
Firm Alleges Bias, Fraud in CBN’s Handling of Excess Bank Charges Refund by First Bank

 

A renowned Forensic and Auditing firm, Lensview Consulting Services has alleged bias, open fraud, deliberate cover-up and impersonation of person by The Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) in the handling of fraudulent transaction charges refund by Nigerian money deposit banks. A case in point is this First Bank of Nigeria Plc, Head Office Branch, Marina – Lagos.

As a follow-up to several other correspondences, on January 20, 2023 the firm wrote to the Governor of the Apex Bank on the fraudulent pervertion, impersonation and miscarriage of Justice by the Consumer Protection Department, an arm of the CBN in a petition titled: Reasonable Suspicion, Likelihood of Bias and Cover up By the Director of the CPD in the Appeal of Judgment between LENSVIEW CONSULTING SERVICES and the CPD with Petition Tracking NUMBER CIM74368/AST involving In First Bank PLC.

Lensview in the letter pointed out and alleged that there was impersonation of its person, fraudulent neglect and non Compliance on the part of officers of the apex bank.

The forensic audit firm had last year approached the Apex bank on behalf of one of its numerous clients to compel First Bank of Nigeria PLc to refund the sum of $227’235.34, being (.50%) of $554,570.68 (Five Hundred and fifty four Thousand, Five hundred and Seventy dollar, Sixty eight cents) as the agreed BANK GUARANTEE FEE . Rather than taking the fee as agreed, FBN took 1% (One percent) which translated to $554,570.68.
On the refusal of FBN to refund the excess of the amount above agreed, and long standing offered rate at .50%, Lensview Consulting petitioned the CBN who after a careful review of the merit of the petition asked FBN to refund same to customer with accrued interest as a standing rule.
It was however surprising that while customers account was being expected to be credited as agreed, FBN who for several months was looking for explanations and documents to explain the transaction, came up with an email chat purported to be between it’s staff and customer’s representative claiming that the GUARANTEE FEE had been increased from .50% to 2%, an offer condition, which the FBN claimed to have been accepted by the customer’s representative who apparently lacked the capacity to accept such on behalf of its principal, or had Company’s mandate powers to instruct or authorize payment or drawings on the principal’s account without confirmation and necessary due diligence from the company who officially requested for the facility, with significantly, a minimum of TWO AUTHORIZED SIGNATURES on it’s Letter Head document for such approvals and payments.
Xxxxxxxx
According to Lensview, the transaction was a heavy one FBN can not claim ignorance they didn’t know that for any change to transaction fees to be effective, it must first be communicated to the customer with a letter with evidence of acknowledgement as a proof that customer is aware of the change.
Lensview also reiterated that FBN was aware that the said company’s representative had not the powers or mandate to authorize such transactions, where he may, it will require at least TWO AUTHORIZED SIGNATURES over the company’s letter of acceptance on their Letter head document and NOT via a chat on phone between two mutual friends.
Given the facts of the matter vis a vis the practice of banking in Nigeria, it’s surprising that the CBN after it’s earlier verdict that refunds be made, it made a sudden U turn that FBN was justified by the fraudulent e mail received from customer’s staff to it to conclude that the e mail SUFFICES as an authority for FBN to take the charge based on instructions from company’s staff without confirmation from Company’s authorized signatories.
The question is, if the e mail content sufficed, why did FBN charge 1% instead 2% Guarantee fee stated in the email?
Who negotiated it from 2% to 1%?
Where is copy of letter from customer acknowledging the new rate which could have been negotiated or rejected if customer saw it?
More worrisome is the CBN’s lack of explanations why the email chat between these mutual friends on behalf of their organization SUFFICED as an AUTHORITY to move such huge amount from customer’s very busy account in the books of FBN.
The CBN in a clever way to cover this fraud as Lensview Consulting pressed harder for justice and explanations why the mail SUFFICED, the CBN in their letter dated 9/1/2023 to Lensview Consulting solicitors wrote that one Mr Polycarp representing Lensview Consulting Services was invited in an interdepartmental meeting with representatives of the CBN in August 2022, whereat the said impersonating Mr. Polycarp affirmed and upheld the unanimous decisions of the CBN vis a vis the fraudulent e mail from FBN was correct and sufficient to close the matter.
According to Mr H.Foss, Managing Consultant, Lensview Consulting Services, the engagement of one pirported Mr Polycarp to stand in for Lensview Consulting Services in the said August 2022 meeting was another fraudulent move by the CBN to cover for FBN in the open e mail fraud.
The CBN in one of their recent letters to Lensview Consulting, wrote to say they have closed the matter based on the affirmation of the impostor consultant they hired to kill the matter.
According to Lensview Consulting, soon as the CBN realized that it had erred by engaging an impostor consultant to stand in for Lensview in the said August 2022 meeting, they quickly wrote back with efforts in futility to withdraw their letter dated 5/1/2023 wherein My Polycarp the impostor was referred to.
See both letters from the CBN to highlight the fraud.