Former Senator Ben Murray-Bruce has called on President Bola Ahmed Tinubu to fundamentally overhaul Nigeria’s electricity sector, arguing that the 2013 privatisation of the power industry has failed to deliver reliable electricity to Nigerians.
In an open letter to the President Bola Tinubu, Murray-Bruce said the country’s electricity crisis had reached a point where the government must abandon what he described as “a national pretence” and adopt a decentralised power model.
He cited figures published by the Nigerian Electricity Regulatory Commission (NERC), saying that of 13,625 megawatts of installed generation capacity, only 4,286 megawatts were available for dispatch as of April.
He also pointed to the collapse of the national grid on August 22, when available generation reportedly dropped to 1,132 megawatts from more than 4,000 megawatts earlier in the day.
“That is not an industry, Your Excellency. That is a rumour of an industry,” he wrote.
Murray-Bruce blamed the challenges partly on the structure of the 2013 privatisation, arguing that the investors who acquired the generating and distribution companies lacked the financial capacity required to develop and maintain the sector.
He said the government should have sold the assets to major multinational operators with the technical expertise and financial strength to make long-term investments in Nigeria’s electricity infrastructure.
According to him, the result has been a sector in which generating companies are owed trillions of naira while the Federal Government continues to commit public funds to keeping the system afloat.
He said the GenCos had claimed they were owed more than ₦7 trillion, while the government had approved a ₦4 trillion bond programme to address liabilities in the sector.
Murray-Bruce also criticised the distribution companies over the continued use of estimated billing, citing figures showing that 5.1 million of Nigeria’s 12.31 million active electricity customers remained unmetered as of February.
He noted that despite the metering gap, the DisCos collected ₦801.16 billion between January and April.
“A meter is a machine that tells the truth. An estimated bill is a machine that does not,” he said, accusing the distribution companies of “billing darkness.”
While acknowledging that GenCos were owed, Murray-Bruce said the companies could not rely indefinitely on government intervention while failing to make the necessary capital investments.
Proposes Community-Based Power Generation
As an alternative, the former senator proposed a decentralised electricity model under which estates, communities and local areas would develop and operate their own power systems.
Using Dolphin Estate in Lagos as an example, he suggested that an estate with about 5,000 families could secure a ₦3 billion bank loan, backed by the state government, to establish a metered solar power system capable of supplying the community.
Residents, he said, could pay for electricity at cost plus a regulated margin, with non-paying customers disconnected in accordance with the law.
He argued that replicating the model across estates, wards and communities nationwide would create new business opportunities while reducing dependence on the national grid.
Murray-Bruce further proposed that state governments should be responsible for powering streetlights, police stations, primary healthcare centres, schools and other State infrastructure largely through solar energy, while the Federal Government should focus on federal institutions and infrastructure.
He said the Minister of Power should consequently function primarily as a coordinator of the electricity sector across the federation rather than attempting to centrally manage the country’s entire power supply.
‘Legal Framework Already Exists’
Murray-Bruce said the legal foundation for decentralising electricity already exists under the Electricity Act 2023, signed by President Tinubu, which removed electricity from the Exclusive Legislative List and enabled states to regulate their electricity markets.
He noted that 17 states had already taken regulatory control of their electricity markets.
“The legal architecture for everything I have described already exists. What is missing is not law. It is nerve,” he said.
He cited the Geometric Power project in Aba as evidence that decentralised electricity generation could work, arguing that the city maintained electricity supply during a national grid collapse because of its independent generation and metered distribution network.
Murray-Bruce also said Nigeria was already spending heavily on unreliable electricity, pointing to the economic losses suffered by households and businesses through generator use and power outages.
He urged Nigerians to hold state governments and local authorities accountable for electricity responsibilities devolved to them under the 2023 law.
“Stop blaming the President for the darkness in your street,” he said, arguing that electricity had become a concurrent responsibility and that states now had greater powers over their electricity markets.
Murray-Bruce concluded by challenging President Tinubu to abandon the existing model and implement a decentralised electricity system, expressing confidence that such a reform could provide electricity to 70 per cent of Nigerians within four years.