…AGF Fagbemi: “No longer business as usual”
…BPP DG: Victory sends strong signal to contractors
Nigeria has recorded another legal victory in an international arbitration after successfully defending claims worth over $6.2 million (about ₦9.3 billion) filed by European Dynamics UK Ltd over a national e-Procurement project.
The dispute, handled through the Bureau of Public Procurement (BPP), ended with the tribunal dismissing all claims against the country in a final ruling not subject to appeal.
The case arose during the administration of President Bola Ahmed Tinubu.
Background to the Dispute
Upon assuming office, BPP Director-General Adebowale Adedokun inherited a stalled technology project alongside ongoing arbitration proceedings.
The contractor had claimed:
$2.4 million for alleged milestone completion,
$3 million general damages, and
$800,000 settlement costs.
The contract involved the design, customisation, installation and maintenance of a national electronic Government Procurement (e-GP) system supported by the World Bank to improve transparency and efficiency in federal procurement.
Although earlier discussions considered an out-of-court settlement, the BPP insisted payment must be tied to verified delivery and continued arbitration.
Nigeria’s legal team, led by Johnson & Wilner LLP with Basil Udotai as lead counsel, reviewed the technical and contractual issues.
Tribunal Findings
Central to the dispute was the User Acceptance Test (UAT), which revealed major system deficiencies and omissions.
Nigeria argued that software delivery is validated only after successful performance testing — not mere installation.
The tribunal agreed, ruling that:
The contractor was responsible for correcting defects at no additional cost.
Approved documents did not waive compliance obligations.
There was no contractual basis for merging project phases.
The contractual framework had been distorted.
All claims were therefore dismissed.
“Nigeria Cannot Be Taken for Granted” — BPP
Adedokun described the ruling as a landmark decision in public sector technology contracting.
“This vendor has sued several African countries and won every case. Nigeria is the first to defeat them. We trusted Nigerian professionals and stood our ground.”
He thanked the Attorney-General for approving the proceedings, noting that billions of naira had been saved for national development.
AGF: A New Era
Responding, Attorney-General of the Federation Lateef Fagbemi praised the legal team and said the judgment sends a global message.
“Nigeria is no longer business as usual. By standing up in this case, we have encouraged other African nations to protect their resources.”
He also credited institutional strengthening efforts under the Tinubu administration.
Implications
The ruling highlights key lessons for government technology projects:
Strict user acceptance testing
Clear milestone definitions
Performance-based payments
Strong contract oversight
Legal advisers urged integration of these lessons into ongoing e-procurement reforms to prevent future disputes.
Statement issued by Kamarudeen Ogundele, SA to the President (Communication & Publicity), Office of the Attorney-General of the Federation.