The Presidential Fiscal Policy and Tax Reforms Committee has pushed back against a recent publication by KPMG on Nigeria’s newly enacted tax laws, saying the report largely misinterpreted policy intent and presented opinions as factual errors.
In a detailed response, the committee acknowledged that some of KPMG’s observations were useful, particularly those relating to implementation risks and clerical or cross-referencing issues. However, it maintained that most of the concerns raised reflected misunderstandings of deliberate policy choices, missed context on broader reform objectives, or preferences different from those adopted by government.
According to the committee, disagreements over policy direction should not be framed as “errors” or “gaps,” noting that other professional firms engaged constructively with government to seek clarification and provide technical input during consultations.
Stock Market, Transition and Global Best Practices
Addressing concerns about the taxation of shares, the committee dismissed fears of a stock market sell-off, explaining that the applicable tax on chargeable gains is not a flat 30 per cent but ranges from 0 to a maximum of 30 per cent, with plans to reduce the top rate to 25 per cent. It added that about 99 per cent of investors qualify for unconditional exemptions, while others are exempt subject to reinvestment.
The committee said the stock market’s record performance and increased investment flows show investor confidence in the reforms, describing claims of a sell-off as unsubstantiated.
On the commencement date of the new laws, it argued that fixing implementation strictly to the start of an accounting period would ignore the complexities of transition across different assessment bases, audits, deductions and credits.
It also defended provisions on indirect transfer of shares, stating that they align with global best practices and Base Erosion and Profit Shifting (BEPS) initiatives aimed at closing long-standing tax loopholes.
Clarifying VAT, Definitions and Dividends
The committee rejected claims of gaps in the VAT treatment of insurance premiums, stressing that insurance is not a taxable supply under Nigerian law and therefore does not require a specific exemption.
It also clarified that the inclusion of “community” in the definition of a taxable person does not create ambiguity, explaining that modern legislative drafting uses comprehensive definitions to avoid repetition. Similarly, it defended the composition of the Joint Revenue Board as intentional and consistent with its revenue-focused mandate.
On dividend taxation, the committee accused KPMG of conflating foreign-controlled companies with foreign operations of Nigerian firms, noting that dividends from foreign companies cannot be franked since no Nigerian withholding tax is deducted.
Policy Choices Under Scrutiny
The committee further rejected proposals it said would undermine reform objectives, including exempting foreign insurance companies from tax on premiums written in Nigeria and allowing tax deductions for foreign exchange sourced from the parallel market. It described these provisions as deliberate fiscal policy choices aimed at protecting local industry, supporting monetary policy and stabilising the naira.
It also defended linking VAT compliance to tax deductibility and maintaining a progressive personal income tax structure. The committee said the top marginal tax rate of 25 per cent for high earners is competitive internationally and balances fairness with economic growth, especially alongside a reduced corporate tax rate.
Correcting Alleged Errors
Responding to claims about the Police Trust Fund, the committee noted that the fund expired in June 2025 after its six-year statutory lifespan, making any call for repeal unnecessary. It also said concerns about small company tax exemptions affecting large firms pre-dated the new laws and were introduced under the Finance Act 2021.
What the Committee Says KPMG Omitted
The committee criticised KPMG for failing to highlight key structural gains of the reforms, including tax harmonisation, the planned reduction in corporate tax rates, expanded input VAT credits, exemptions for low-income earners and small businesses, elimination of minimum tax on turnover and capital, and enhanced investment incentives for priority sectors.
Way Forward
The committee said the tax reforms followed extensive stakeholder consultations and public hearings, adding that minor clerical issues are already being identified and addressed. It described the overhaul as a bold step toward a self-sustaining and competitive Nigerian economy.
It urged stakeholders to move from “static critique” to constructive engagement, stressing that effective implementation will rely on administrative guidance, regulatory clarifications and continued collaboration between government and the private sector.