Germany’s Constitutional Court on Wednesday rejected an attempt by six politicians from the pro-business Free Democratic Party (FDP) to abolish the additional tax originally introduced to finance the costs of German reunification.
The court ruled that the government still had legitimate financial needs related to reunification but emphasised that the so-called solidarity surcharge could not be permanent.
The judges also stated that the tax could become unconstitutional if the need for it disappeared.
A ruling against the surcharge could have created a 12.75 billion euros (13.8 billion dollars) gap in 2025 federal budget and potentially required the government to repay around 65 billion euros collected since 2020.
The FDP challengers argued that the surcharge no longer had a legal basis after the end of Solidarity Pact II in 2019, which aimed to narrow the economic gap between East and West Germany.
They also claimed that the tax unfairly targeted high earners, while most taxpayers no longer paid it.
Since 2021, only top earners, companies, and investors have been required to pay the 5.5 per cent surcharge on income, corporate, and capital gains taxes.
The court, however, found no violation of the principle of equality.
The German government defended the tax in court, citing ongoing reunification costs and asserting that the surcharge did not need to be tied to specific expenses.