Home News Kano poll controversy: Police, NNPP protesters clash, more cloud over judgment

Kano poll controversy: Police, NNPP protesters clash, more cloud over judgment

0
Kano poll controversy: Police, NNPP protesters clash, more cloud over judgment

Youths believed to be supporters of the New Nigeria People’s Party on Wednesday stormed the Kofar Nasarawa area of the  Kano metropolis in protest against the alleged contradictions in the judgment of the Court of Appeal, which sacked the state Governor, Abba Yusuf.

The youth after attending a special prayer organised for the governor by the residents of the area at 2 pm started the protest.

The protesters clashed with policemen dispatched to the area to quell the protest.

As youths protested in Kano, confusion over the judgment persisted on Wednesday as the NNPP and the Labour Party dismissed the statements of the Court of Appeal and the All Progressive Congress that the mix-up in the Certified True Copy of the judgment was a mere clerical error.

The appellate court had in its judgment on Friday reaffirmed the sacking of the governor by the state election petitions tribunal.

 He said, “When you want to commit a crime, one way or the other, you will leave a trace or unnoticed clue that will lead to your arrest. What we have seen here is that the judiciary, by God’s intervention, left a clue to expose them and their dirty dealings. In this case, they didn’t even leave one. There were about three clues that show they were not able to clinically deal with their crime against the people. But it will not stand.’’

APC’s stand

But the All Progressives Congress dismissed allegations by the opposition parties, insisting that its candidate, Dr Nasiru Gawuna, won the appeal.

At a press conference on Wednesday, the National Legal Adviser of the APC, Prof Abdulkareem Kana, attributed the mix-up in the CTC to clerical errors.

He stated,  “Those of us who are lawyers know that typographic errors often occur in certified true copies of court judgments. Ordinarily, there wouldn’t have been confusion if it was not a political matter. It will not be the first time such typographic mistakes will be seen in judgments and being lawyers, we are used to a situation like this. All that is required is to merely correct the mistake. The most important thing is a judgment that was read in open court.

“In a situation like this, what we lawyers do is a community reading of the entire judgment to see the exact finding of the court. For anyone who reads the judgment from page one all the way to page 72, you will agree most certainly that assertion will not hold water instead of upholding the judgment of the lower court, it sets it aside.

“I don’t think the explanation needs to come from us. But for us, we can only render our own perspective as a party to the entire uproar that is going on. But as to the explanation of where the error happened in the cause of typing the judgment, it is for the court to provide an explanation. I am sure the court would have done that by now by taking necessary measures to issue a fresh CTC with respect to an appropriate judgment of the court. So for me, I don’t think there is any confusion anywhere except for those who prefer to continue to see it as confusion.”

Clerical error

Also, the Chief Registrar of the Court of Appeal, Umar Mohammed Bangari,  said there was no contradiction in the judgment.

In a statement in Abuja on Wednesday, he stated, “What happened in the part of the judgment is just a mere clerical error that ought not to draw any issue. The court is empowered to correct such clerical errors and would be done as appropriate.

“The clerical error would be rectified once parties in the matter file formal application to that effect. Order 23 Rule 4 of the Court of Appeal Handbook empowers the court to correct any clerical error once detected by the court or any of the parties in the matter.  However, contrary to insinuations, the judgment of the court remains valid.”

Meanwhile,  the governor, on Wednesday filed an appeal at the Supreme Court, challenging his removal as by the appeal court last week.

The notice of appeal was filed by the  NNPP and Yusuf joined the Independent National Electoral Commission, the APC and its governorship candidate as respondents.

The document, which lists 10 grounds of appeal against the judgement of the appellate court, seek three reliefs from the Supreme Court, as follows:

“An order allowing the appeal and setting aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal delivered on 17th November 2023.

“An order upholding the portion of the judgment of the court of appeal setting aside the judgment of the trial tribunal in petition No: EPT/RV/GOV/11/2023 and making an order as costs in favour of the appellant.

He also faulted the judgment, describing it as a grave miscarriage of justice.