Home News Wike not answerable to N’Assembly — Falana, Adegboruwa

Wike not answerable to N’Assembly — Falana, Adegboruwa

0
Wike not answerable to N’Assembly — Falana, Adegboruwa

Senior Advocates of Nigeria, Femi Falana and Ebun-Olu Adegboruwa, have waded into the dispute between the Minister of the Federal Capital Territory, Nyesom Wike, and the Senator representing the FCT, Ireti Kingibe.

The senior lawyers noted that the FCT minister in terms of execution of duties was not answerable to Kingibe or the National Assembly.

The FCT lawmaker had warned Wike to desist from working without the supervision of the National Assembly.

Kingibe also noted that the FCT minister does not have executive powers but must operate within the constitutional frameworks of the country’s legislative arm.

Kingibe said, “You also have to remember that the minister of the FCT – I’m not sure we have had a former governor as a minister, I think we have had one. Some [former] governors may think that as an FCT minister, the minister does not have executive powers. He works hand-in-hand with the National Assembly and the president to administer the FCT.”

However, interpreting the constitution, Falana stated that Kingibe was wrong to have said that the minister was answerable to the National Assembly in the discharge of his duties.

He said, “The distinguished senator is wrong. The power of the executive with respect to the FCT lies with the President. Making laws and passing laws for the FCT are the business of the National Assembly.

“By designation, anybody could be appointed to hold any position in the FCT. Just like in the case of the FCT, you’d see that all FCT High Court judges are occupied by people all over the country.

“So, it is not correct to say that appointment into the FCT must be limited to the indigenes, though I believe they should be carried along. But that cannot be a validation to discredit the minister.”

Meanwhile, the senior lawyers kicked against the demolition of structures stating that proper procedures must be followed for such activities to be carried out.

Falana said that neither the President, the minister nor the governor of a state had the power to demolish the property of any citizen in Nigeria without following the proper process.

Falana said, “The President, governor, or minister cannot decide that a house has been built without approved plans and then proceed to demolish without a court order.”

He stated that in each of the states and the FCT, the relevant law is the Physical Planning Act, under that the relevant law is the Urban and Regional Planning law and under these laws, there is a provision for demolishing a house or property.

He expressed, “Without complying with such a law, nobody has the power to demolish a house. In fact, under any of such laws, there is usually an agency set up to investigate whether somebody has violated the urban and regional planning law.

“If you’re dissatisfied with the decision of that agency, there is an appellate committee. In other words, if a demolition notice is pasted on my building or structure, I have the right to disagree with you.

“So, an agency in the Ministry of Physical Planning would examine my complaint and make a decision and if I also disagree with that decision, there is an appellate committee to review the decision of the agency.”

Falana added, “In the case of Lagos State, if you’re dissatisfied with the decision of the appellate committee, there is a provision to go to the High Court which shall within a specified period of time decide the case.

“Just as a private person cannot demolish someone else’s property, the government cannot also demolish the property of a citizen.

“So, you cannot come out to say these structures were not on the building plan. Who are you? Because you’re a governor or a minister? So, you have now constituted yourself as the complaint witness.

“Since the government operates under the Rule of Law, the government is under a duty to conduct its duties under the relevant laws.”

He explained that if the government was going to demolish any building, there was a procedure, and the government could not just wake up and surround a person’s house with bulldozers and raze the building to the ground without a court order.