By Aishatu Alheri
First and foremost, I wish to declare that I am a Muslim and my understanding of death is a passage allowed by Almighty Allah. No one can die except God allows it. This explains why real Muslims don’t dwell on excessive ceremonies in death of either young or old. This is why burials are with dispatch. Not that we don’t mourn but we do so with an innate belief that we can commit any untoward event to the hand of the almighty Allah.
Over the last two weeks, the public narrative space though filled with the cacophony of politics, has also managed to accommodate, as has become the tradition within the Nigerian cyber sphere, a melange of the extremely dramatic, and also seriousness.
However, during this period, we have also witnessed the tragic death of a 12 year old student of Chrisland School, Lagos, during the school’s annual inter-house sports competition. A very unfortunate event, made even more heartbreaking because she was still a minor. That must have been quite a traumatic experience not just for the parents, but also for the school also.
I noticed however, that deluge of commentary within the media space seems to have emanated mostly from the parents, especially the mother. The parents are understandably distraught, and we all handle grief differently, thus the frequent media klieg lights being beamed on the family and numerous social media posts on different platforms may be their own way of easing off the pains of the loss. You cannot teach people how to grief.
However, the ways and manner most of the so-called ‘influencers’ prey on people grieving either loss of loved ones, property, or even money demands caution. While some of the bloggers pretend to care for the victims, they are only after the monetized traffic they attract to their blogs or their news platforms. To them the victims or the bereaved are simply another employed tool to attract attention and or momentum to their blogs. And very soon another news break would come along relegating this to the background. That’s media mercantilism at its selfish best.
That is basically why Chrisland School’s refusal to engage in same manner over this loss, should be commended instead of pilloried. I have heard comments across social media demanding to know the school’s side of the story. While we seem to have grown accustomed to the constant media glitz and blitz occasioned by access to different social media platforms, Chrisland School’s silence in the face of barrages of claims and counter claims, and deliberate refusal to acknowledge or debunk allegations made against them for me, might appear cold but in other interpretations might connote a deliberate decision to demonstrate remorse fans deep respect for the memory of their student.
Knowing how the School has responded and engaged the media in the past especially when they had issues, is a pointer that the silence wasn’t out of disregard for the right of the public to know, but out of deep reverence for the memory of the young lady.
I could recall when the news broke in the media about a report by the actress Mercy Johnson on bullying in the school which affected her child, news reports came out later that the grievance was resolved and both school and the Nollywood Actresss I think, issues a joint statement. I remember telling a colleague, “Chrisland dodged Bullet”, because Mercy Johnson is one of my very favorite artists and I was going to come down hard on the school. That joint statement took the wind off my sail and I couldn’t cry more than the bereaved.
When the School had another issue regarding their students during an excursion to Dubai, UAE, which attracted lots of media attention, the school was visibly present in combing and dominating the media space to tell her own story.
Their position on this issue, however, reminds me of the decision of Dr. Martin Luther King who on April 4, 1967, delivered a major public statement against the Vietnam War, entitled “Beyond Vietnam: A Time to Break the Silence.” While condemning the war, Dr. King pointed out that he had to speak up because of his belief that “A time comes when silence is betrayal. Dr Martin Luther King earlier kept quiet while studying the situation because it is always important to have a full grasp of a situation before delving into it.
Now that the School has sent out a statement highlighting some issues the public were unaware of, for example, they were the one that insisted on an autopsy, and they wrote the State government demanding for it. Or that they they “have been cooperating with the authorities” in this case. It is now time for Nigerians to start asking some of the unasked questions without prejudice to the ongoing investigations as the report of the Coroner’s Inquest is ongoing, pointing to electrocution as being responsible for the death of the student, Whitney Adediran.
Should we not be asking how come such a tragedy occurred in a public sports facility?
This is because the sports ground is not a property of Chrisland school, if the said victim was electrocuted within the school premises, in classroom , dormitory or any other school owned facility, it would have made the case easier and the blames appropriately apportioned without mincing words. But this happened at a public owned sports facility. How come a public facility does not have a medical centre, a paramedic team, or even an ambulance?
Nigeria has had too many cases of tragedies at sports facilities but never seem to learn anything from such incidents. For a country that lost one of its best footballers in a tragic situation that could have been salvaged if there was adequate medical facility, we should by now, be better situated to handle such eventualities. Legendary midfielder of the Super Eagles of Nigeria Sam Okwaraji died during a football match against Angola at the National Stadium in Lagos on August 12, 1989.
On October 29, 1995, Nigeria lost another talented footballer named Amir Angwe who had collapsed at the Onikan National Stadium during the African Cup Winners semi-final match where he had represented Julius Berger of Nigeria against Maxaquene of Mozambique.
On March 8, 2020, a footballer, Chineme Martins who played for Nassarawa United in the Nigerian Football Premier League, slumped on the pitch during a game against Kastina United. He had been taken to the hospital, where he was pronounced dead. He could have lived, if there were adequate medical facilities at the stadium at the time of the incident.
On December 12, 2010, young footballer Emmanuel Ogoli collapsed on the pitch while playing for his club side, the Ocean Boys. He was taken to the hospital, where he finally gave up the ghost
When you juxtaposed the few mentioned cases above with the report of the Danish international Christian Eriksen who, about a year ago, collapsed on the pitch during the 2020 Euro finals against Finland in Copenhagen. According to the team doctor, Morten Boesen , “he was gone” for a few minutes and revived after cardiac resuscitation, and this happened on live television as the world watched. Without adequate medical facilities and personnel, he would have died like the many other Nigerian footballers.
So when are we ready to address some of the inadequacies especially at public spaces, and also institute more strict regulations for the use of public facilities because if there were strict regulations and well trained personnel to ensure implementation, maybe, a live wire, or poorly connected live wires would not have been carelessly left in the open in a facility young children are using.
What happened to Whitney Adediran, as unfortunate and regrettable as it was, could have happened to another kid, from another school that is not Chrisland meaning that time has come for us as a people to use such tragedies as a learning curve to address safety lapses within our public spaces instead of using it to engage in endless media battles.
In other societies, such tragedies call for sober reflections, and demands for more safety controls. It could be remembered that the child resistant packages we see in drug packs today were invented after several accidents involving children opening drug packs and ingesting the contents leading to casualties. This led the United States Congress to pass the Poison Prevention Packaging Act of 1970, saving millions of lives in the process. Serious societies use tragedies as a learning curve to prevent future occurrences, in Nigeria, we huff and puff, and forget, and wait for the next tragedy. That should change.
Let us immortalise the memory of Whitney Adediran by getting government agencies and schools to take more safety cautious measures both within schools, and outside of school premises such as sports grounds, and also for every sports ground to have well equipped medical facilities and personnel on ground during events. I also don’t think procuring one ambulance to cover different days of inter house sports should be too much for Chrisland considering you are a private institution with between class A to B patronage.
It is commendable reading from the statement by the School few days ago that they are making concrete plans at immortalizing the memory of Whitney Adediran. That to me should be able to bring this unfortunate incident to a desirable closure. Having said that, Chrisland School requires a major surgery at this moment. Your reputation is in tatters. You cannot continue this way. Get your processes in order. If heads of those responsible for your occasional faux pas have to roll, let the heads roll. This is one bad news too many! Unfortunately, even the Public is mistaking the last death at Dowen college for Chrisland school student’s death.
This is the bad effect of how your name resonates. You have work to do to change this trajectory.
A word of caution for Whitney’s parents especially the mother.
I am sad that you went through this and I pray the almighty Allah will console you. This is a long walk and only God himself can speed up the healing. However, you can achieve a lot for the memory of Whitney than a consistent agony party on social media. Nigerians will move on after a while and it will be you alone. All the “I am with you” that you’re reading are mostly lip service. Don’t allow people to use you to revitalize their relevance. You have done well fighting to draw authorities attention to your plight. This is now the time to have an introspection and demand for your privacy. Media is a slippery terrain and you don’t want to expose yourself so much that you become the target on a day you become the news item to sell. Media will not shelter you. Hope my two cents drives home the point.
May Whitney’s memory be a blessing.
*Aishatu, writes from Kaduna*.