Home News Stakeholders Oppose Proposed Law on Human Fertilisation and Surrogacy By Lagos Assembly

Stakeholders Oppose Proposed Law on Human Fertilisation and Surrogacy By Lagos Assembly

0
Stakeholders Oppose Proposed Law on Human Fertilisation and Surrogacy By Lagos Assembly

 

 

BY TAIWO OGUNMOLA-OMILANI

Stakeholders at the Lagos State House of Assembly have opposed a bill to regulate human fertilization and surrogacy in the state.

They spoke during a public hearing held in the assembly on Wednesday on a bill to regulate human fertilization and surrogacy procedure and practice, and prohibit certain practices in connection with embryos and gametes in the state, and for connected purposes.

The stakeholders told the house to re-draft the Human Fertilisation and Surrogacy Regulatory Authority bill, 2021, saying that there is a need for the inclusion of the Association of Fertility Reproductive Health experts in the drafting of the bill.

In his contribution, Professor Oladapo Ashiru said that the process of providing IVF services in Lagos State started in 1979/1980. “We went all over the world and did many types of research and we have perfected the process.

“I am the Secretary of the Society of Fertility and Reproductive Health Experts. The terminology used in the bill is wrong. We used Assisted Reproductive Technology. I feel sad that the document was produced without the input of the Association of Fertility Reproductive Health expert”, he said.

Asiru stated that the bill cannot stand the test of time if passed into law.

The professor, who condemned some terms used in the bill said that the laws passed by the Senate and the houses are meant to address issues and that the technicality is left to the experts.

According to him, We have a whole document on Assisted Reproductive Technology, (ART). The committee should look at what exists in the state and improve on it. The present law, in its present form l, should be stepped down.

Mrs. Toyin Lolu Ogunmade, who got twins from a surrogate mother shared her story of how she could not conceive as a result of fibroid.

“I had to contract a surrogate mother because I couldn’t conceive a child because I had fibroid. At that time, nobody wanted to do surrogacy for me and there was no way I could get a family member or friend to do it.

“I waited for 12 to 13 years. I went to India and an Indian helped me to carry my twins, who look so much like me. They are not Indians and they still have a relationship with their surrogate mother.

“I have been helping people to reduce stigmatization. It is not anybody’s choice to go through surrogacy. I can have a child, I only had a problem with my health. The bill will cause more damage than good.

“The bill would promote what we are trying to avoid such as trafficking or baby factory. We are ready to partner with you. I have spoken about it and even wrote a book about it”, she said.

Olaronke Thaddeus of Meet Surrogate Mothers Agency described the bill as anti-reproduction and anti-women.

“Surrogacy agencies are completely left out. We have done a lot and we have had many children. Surrogacy agencies should function very well in Nigeria. We have an association. In the latter part of the law, the punishment for offenders is too much.

“If any parent should wait for five years before embarking on surrogacy, this would be too long. Surrogacy doesn’t stand alone, it should be part of IVF. The clinic is called an IVF hospital, not a surrogacy clinic.

Dr. Omoruyi Ivie added that having children through surrogacy is not a choice for women, but that it is caused by the condition.

“It is wrong to ask a woman to pick a relative or friend for surrogacy. There is a minimum number of eggs required for a circle. What happens when you cannot use donor eggs? We must factor in the women,” she said.

Mr. Uwa Iletoge said that the authority is saddled with the responsibility and the appointment of board members in the bill should be democratic.

“It should not be an appendage of any government. The key stakeholders should be involved. If we don’t have good board members to do the right thing, people will derail”, he said.

Dr. Faye Iketubosin, past president of the Association of Fertility And Reproductive Health condemned the terminologies used in the bill.

“I worked with a committee that worked on the practice of ART in Lagos State. We worked for four years to generate a document on ART in the state.

“We have been self-regulating. There is something to amend on almost every page. A committee involving the practitioners and stakeholders should come together and work on the bill. Let us enact the right law,” he said.

In his response, Hon. Bisi Yusuf, a member of the House Committee on Health said that
there must be regulated the society and the bill is not yet a law.

 

“it is still a bill, you can make your contributions and we will include them. We have been exposed to law-making. It should not be a surprise that you will get information from us that we need your contributions.

“Whatever the Lagos State Government does is a product of our laws,” he said.